A humorous philosophical investigation into the existence of santafrom a coexecutive producer of the big bang theory metaphysics isnt ordinarily much of a laughing matter. Scientific proof that santa does exist here are the answers to those questions your children ask you about the proof of santas existence. It is hard to believe that one man, great and all as he is, can produce pre sents for hundreds of. I remember hearing the true origin of santa claus being based on a russian, european or middleeastern saint named saint nicholas who would give out gifts or. The huffington post kaplans deadpan style lets you read this as a serious philosophical treatisebut you can also take it as a welldone farce. This is one of 5 reasons santa probably does not exist.
Convince others of your answer to the question, does santa exist. Read does santa claus existissue 2 online for free at. Why santa doesnt exist its winter and holiday season is upon us. On his way to an answer, kaplan takes the reader on a wild ride through philosophy, science, mysticism, and mortality. It would be as dreary as if there were no virginias. Posted on october 17, 2014 by sean carroll theres a claim out there one that is about 95% true, as it turns out that if you pick a wikipedia article at random, then click on the first nontrivial link, and keep clicking on the first link of each subsequent article, you will end up at philosophy.
I am not a single man who makes millions of toys each year, and gives them all out in one long night on a sled pulled by 8 or 9 magical reindeer. But your husband does not live at the north pole, own flying. Santa, meanwhile, will be subjected to centrifugal forces 17,500. I can tell that he really wants to believe but that he is starting to question the idea inside of his head. Using buddhism as his primary source, kaplan explains how selfcontradiction could be embraced to justify both the existence of santa and his nonexistence. The funding problem i know that it may be difficult to think critically about some of the beliefs that you hold sacred many atheists struggle with this as well as i pointed out in my article 5 reasons atheism is a crutch but.
Your browser does not currently recognize any of the video formats available. A child would definitely say yes, but those of us who say no, dont know the scientific reasons as to why santa cannot exits, and the reason there is no such thing as magic does not count. Kaplan uses the question does santa exist as a starting point for discussion on philosophy, if a narrow after a breezy and easy to follow opening in which kaplan explored different parts of philosophy, it morphed into a personal theory that was harder to follow and too personal it became about kaplan, rather than kaplan using his experience to illustrate points. Eric kaplans son had a zoo trip canceled because one mom worried about reindeerinduced questions. Kaplan shows how philosophy giants bertrand russell and ludwig wittgenstein strove to smooth over this uncomfortable meeting of the real and unrealand failed. A humorous philosophical investigation into the existence of sant. If satan exists but is not interested in humans, many are cautious or even fearful without reason. The editorial appeared in the september 21, 1897, edition of the new york sun and has since become part of popular christmas folklore in the united states. The mission of worldcrunch to deliver the best and most trusted sources of news, regardless of language or geography is more vital than ever. Help your kid brother feel better by crafting a counterargument in this holiday version of a persuasive essay. Though there was a person whom the myth was based on, santa claus is a madeup figure. Though the modern santa claus is associated with a world of fantasy, the. His existence would insist upon evidence, and there is none. A philosophical investigation a witty, provocative, and profound exploration of reality, meaning, morality, and yes, santa claus.
Does santa exist a philosophical investigation youtube. There are 2 billion children under 18 in the world. To believe in santa claus is akin to saying magic exists, a statement which i believe, and hope, is disregarded by most people. October 18, 2014 eric kaplans son had a zoo trip canceled because one.
More specifically, you will end up at a loop that runs through reality, existence. In conclusion if santa ever did deliver presents on christmas eve, hes dead now. It is the most reprinted newspaper editorial in the english language. Help your child defend jolly old saint nicholas with this persuasive essay exercise. Or you could just let them know hes fake, but its funnice to pretend. For most people this means last minute shopping for gifts, unless you are a child and believe its actually santa clause who will deliver the presents to your. Yes, virginia, there is a santa claus eightyearold virginia ohanlon wrote a letter to the editor of new yorks sun, and the quick response was printed as an unsigned editorial sept. Aha, you say, jeanluc has matterantimatter warp engines, santa only has reindeer, where does he get the power to move that fast. Does santa exist a philosophical investigation by eric kaplan in djvu, doc, txt download ebook. Also, ideally you make sure that christmas isnt about santa and that your kid doesnt idolize him, so when they get older they arent hurt by the truth. That combination of livelihoods led to his strange and delightful new book, does santa exist a philosophical.
The work of veteran newsman francis pharcellus church has since become historys most reprinted newspaper editorial, appearing in part or whole in dozens of languages in books. Can santa claus exist according to the laws of physics. But there are 300,000 species of living organisms yet to be classified, and while most of these are insects and germs, this does not completely rule out flying reindeer, which only santa has seen. Thats a lot of research and information you gave, however, santa clause does not currently exist. Without this part of the tradition you have to acknowledge the holiday for what it has become, a consumerist nightmare designed to make money for companies. Santa claus is a legend or mythical person based on an actual human being who lived in ancient times.
The conclusion despite the fact that classical machanics cannot describe santa, quantum mechanical description is much more successful. Eric kaplan, a coexecutive producer of the big bang theory, wrote a humorous philosophical investigation into the existence of santa called does santa exist. However, if satan is a deceptive manipulator, then he is more dangerous than most people imagine. Yes, virginia, there is a santa claus is a phrase from an editorial called is there a santa claus. From there he turns to mysticisms attempts to resolve such paradoxes.
My son and my daughter both believe in santa claus. The part of the myth when he comes down your chimney was created when saint nickolas climbed up a house and through the presents down the chimney. Read does santa claus existissue 1 online for free at. Comedy writer, philosophy scholar, and coexecutive producer of the hit show the big bang theory, kaplan begins his elliptical examination of the ontology of santa claus by introducing readers to a con. Yes, adults do lie to children, and yes, they do buy presents. Quotes showing of 3 in the life cycle of a theory, it starts off simple and then gets fancier and fancier, as brainy thinkers mount objections and the theorys proponents develop more subtle, complex, and welldefended theory to stave them off. There are quite a few reasons as to why its impossible for santa to exist and ill explore them. From there he turns to mysticisms attempts to resolve such paradoxes, surveying buddhism, taoism, early christianity, theosophy, and even the philosophers at uc. Nick becomes a deeply insightful, laughoutloud discussion of the way some things exist but may not really be therejust like santa and his reindeer. The name santa claus is the english form of the dutch name for st.
My 8yearold son tom stormed into the house one december afternoon. Recently, however, my son is starting to hear a lot from his peers about santa and has been asking a lot of questions. Uh oh, some mean kids have made an argument that santa doesnt exist. Either you are lying about santas existence, or you are lying. A humorous philosophical investigation into the existence of santa from a coexecutive producer of the big bang theorythe perfect. Richard dawkins boasts that he tried to tell a sixyearold child that father christmas didnt exist. A study in physics the workload there are 2 billion children in the world, but since santa doesnt appear to handle the muslim, hindu, jewish and buddhist children, that reduces his work load to 15 percent of the total, or 300 million. A 250pound santa which seems ludicrously slim would be pinned to the back of his sleigh by 4,315,015 pounds of force. Does santa exist a philosophical investigation kindle edition by eric kaplan. Does santa exist a philosophical investigation by eric. Well, what does the question mean and what does it mean to you. Does santa exist a philosophical investigation by eric kaplan. But there are 300,000 species of living organisms yet to be classified, and while most of these are insects and germs, this does not completely rule out flying reindeer which only santa has ever seen.
Santa helps christmas be special because christmas asks people to believe in a kind of spiritual event and puts spirituality into it because santa claus can obly exist through magic. The coronavirus crisis is bringing the world into our lives like never before. The legend of santa claus can be traced back hundreds of years to a monk named st. He glides effortlessly from the santa story to important questions in logic, ethics, psychology, and the social function of myth. We hope that you enjoy this resource, merry christmas. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. If you loved this resource checkout our christmas resources we hope that you enjoy this resource. A humorous philosophical investigation into the existence of santa from a coexecutive producer of the big bang theory metaphysics isnt ordinarily much of a laughing matter. In mysticism, paradox is a fundamental tool for understanding how we exist. Here is a list of scientific breakthroughs, that can put your mind at rest, so you can stop running around trying to.
A humorous philosophical investigation into the existence of santafrom a coexecutive producer of the big bang theory metaphysics isnt ordinarily much of. Does santa exist a philosophical investigation free. I just dont think youre part of the scientific worldview. You can read online does santa exist here in pdf, epub, mobi or docx formats. It is believed that nicholas was born sometime around 280 a. Well, if satan does not exist, those who accept him as real are misled.
The huffington post kaplans deadpan style lets you read this as a serious philosophical treatise but you can also take it as a welldone farce. Does santa exist a philosophical investigation kindle edition by. A thousand years from now, virginia, nay 10 times 10,000 years from. The work of veteran newsman francis pharcellus church has since become historys most reprinted newspaper editorial, appearing in part or whole in dozens of languages in books, movies, and.
215 1197 104 1439 677 206 187 351 1200 373 986 946 1431 1109 829 37 1247 435 1199 468 243 974 338 380 953 403 797 304 1301 86 88 893 188 1396 442 1219 833 949 915 518